Were these players better for SAFC or NUFC?

Jack Colback in the Sunderland colours.
Jack Colback in the Sunderland colours.
11
Have your say

They’ve donned both the red and white, and black and white - but when were they better?

Check out our Tinder-style selector on footballers who’ve played for both SAFC and NUFC. Give them a thumbs up if they were better for Sunderland - or a thumbs down if they were better for Newcastle.