Campaigner suggests way to save millions by re-using doomed South Shields School site

A campaigner has called on council chiefs to consider saving a doomed £24million school from closure – by demolishing a community centre and switching its services.

Outspoken Colin Campbell believes flattening Chuter Ede Community Association could solve the problem of what to do with South Shields School, which is due to close next year.

Colin Cammpbell

Colin Cammpbell

Under his plan, the community centre – a former school in Galsworthy Road, Biddick Hall – would be flattened and its considerable land assets freed for revenue-raising housing.

At the same time, he says, its services would be moved to the South Shields School site – around a mile away in Nevinson Avenue, Whiteleas, which could then operate as a community centre.

Mr Campbell, of Cleadon Meadows, Cleadon, says this would satisfy the terms of the Private Finance Initiative (PFI) funding deal under which the school opened in September 2011.

The contract states the under-performing school, which councillors last week voted to close in 2020, can only be used for educational purposes, limiting future operational opportunities – and costing the council millions of pounds in repayments.

South Shields School

South Shields School

Related: South Shields School WILL close, despite efforts to keep it open

The housing landlord said: “This is the perfect solution and the ideal way of saving South Shields School.

“Chuter Ede needs some repairs and an upgrade – closing it and moving the work it does to the school is a good idea.

“It sits on a considerable amount of land, which could be built on, raising much-needed revenue for the council.

Damage to the marked police vehicle following the incident.

Damage to the marked police vehicle following the incident.

“As far as I know, the council owns the land, meaning it would benefit from all the money that would come from housing.

“The site is large enough to keep some as a green space to satisfy environmental criteria.”

Related: ‘No plans’ for doomed multi-million South Shields School site, say council chiefs after voting to close it

South Tyneside Council is obliged to pay towards the upkeep and maintenance of the school, at an estimated cost of about £400,000 a year, until 2036.

The school’s difficulties stem from an ‘inadequate’ rating by education standards inspectorate Ofsted and a failure to find a backer to sponsor it as an academy.

It also has capacity for 850 pupils yet has only about 550 filled places.

Members of the council’s Cabinet committee voted for its closure at a meeting last Wednesday, a move which angered campaigners who wanted it to remain open.

Related: South Shields School closure: Head tells of ‘deep disappointment’

In response to Mr Campbell’s proposal, a council spokesman said: “We understand how difficult the consultation on closure has been for the students and their parents and carers.

“The education of our young people remains a core priority for the council. We are absolutely committed to supporting the entire school community and the focus now is on making sure the transition to alternative schools is as smooth as possible.

“No plans for future use of the site have been considered at this stage as that would have been inappropriate during the consultation process.”