MPs support call for end to NHS pay cap after Government avoids embarrassing defeat

MPs have backed a call for an end to the public sector pay cap for the NHS after the Government chose not to contest a Labour motion rather than face an embarrassing Commons defeat.
The Government faced an embarrassing defeat if they challenged Labour's motion.The Government faced an embarrassing defeat if they challenged Labour's motion.
The Government faced an embarrassing defeat if they challenged Labour's motion.

The Conservatives had faced the prospect of losing a vote on the non-binding motion after their Democratic Unionist (DUP) allies made clear they would vote with the opposition.

DUP deputy leader Nigel Dodds said the motion was not covered by the "confidence and supply" arrangement agreed by the two parties after Theresa May saw her majority wiped out in last June's general election.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

"Lifting the cap on nurses' pay and in the public sector generally is our party policy. The Government understood that is the way that we were going to vote," Mr Dodds told Sky News following the debate.

"It is not part of the confidence and supply arrangements. We are separate parties, we are not part of the Government and we will make up our own mind on those issues."

Conservative sources insisted they were "pretty relaxed" about the outcome of the debate which does not require the Government to change policy.

It comes the day after ministers effectively ended the pay cap with the announcement of rises above the 1 per cent limit for police and prison officers.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

For Labour, shadow health secretary Jonathan Ashworth called on ministers to make clear whether they intended to ignore the "clear will of the House" or take action to end the pay cap in the NHS.

"It's extremely rare for the Government not to vote down an opposition motion and the only explanation is it avoided a vote because it knew it would lose it," he said.

"The Labour Party is no longer just the official opposition, we are a government in waiting, ready to properly invest in our NHS and its staff."

During the debate Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt labelled the Labour motion as "bogus" and said it was "absolute nonsense" to suggest the cap over the last seven years was part of an "ideological mission" to reduce the size of the state.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

However he faced some calls from the Tory benches to lift the cap with Sarah Wollaston, who chairs the Health Select Committee, arguing that it had gone on for long enough.

"Seven years of a sustained pressure on NHS pay is taking a toll, and nobody anticipated it would go on this long. So I think it is time to relax it," she said.