Newcastle United lost their first home game since January after a 1-0 defeat to Crystal Palace.
Our Newcastle writer Miles Starforth has dished out his player ratings following the game - scroll down and flick through our gallery to see how each player performed.
Didn't have a shot to save until Milivojevic's second-half penalty. 6 Clumsily conceded the second-half penalty which cost United at least a point. 4 Stretchered off to a standing ovation from fans after suffering an injury. 6 Defended well and helped limit Palace to just one shot on target. 6 Recalled to team after serving a ban and recovering from concussion, strolled through most of the game. 6 Got on the front foot in the first half and combined well with Almiron at times. 6 Put in a competitive performance after passing a pre-game fitness test. 6 Steady performance before making way for Shelvey. 6 Didn't get into the game and wasn't a threat up front. 5 Had some bright moments in the first 45 minutes, but faded after the break. 6 Had a goal ruled out for offside, but should have done better with a first-half header. 5 Defended well after coming on. 6