First half goal from Sado Djalo, Robbie Dale and Nathan Buddle put Blyth in control at half-time before a second half fightback from Newcastle Under-23s saw Jay Turner-Cooke and Santiago Munoz find the net.
Here are our player ratings from the match...
5. Matthew Bondswell - 5
Gave opposition plenty of space to threaten down his side. Booked. Photo: Stu Forster
6. Niall Brookwell - 6
Sprayed the ball around well, just didn’t see enough of it.
7. Lucas De Bolle - 5
A quiet display by his standards.
8. Tom Allan - 6
Saw a close range effort saved in the second half. Got into some decent areas.