'Absolutely devastated' - Campaigners lose major battle against housing plans on South Tyneside green belt

Government inspector delivers sickening blow to campaigners’ hopes of preventing the construction of 1,200 development on Green Belt land in Jarrow.

Campaigners have told of their devastation at losing a major battle to stop a giant new housing estate being built on acres of South Tyneside Green Belt.

Members of the Save the Fellgate Green Belt Working Group.placeholder image
Members of the Save the Fellgate Green Belt Working Group. | National World

They have expressed dismay that a government planning inspector has found “exceptional circumstances” to allow the 1,200-home development on farmland at Fellgate in Jarrow.

It is one of three significant chunks of Green Belt that will be lost to housing after conditional approval was given to the borough council’s Local Plan - its 15-year strategy around growth and sustainability.

The others are at Cleadon, where around 259 homes are planned next to Sunderland Road and Moor Lane, and 400 houses in a border zone between South Tyneside and Sunderland at Town End Farm.

At both sites, inspector David Spencer said he found the same exceptional circumstances as at Fellgate to allow housebuilding, describing the borough’s housing shortfall as “severe”.

Overall, he agreed with the council that 309 new homes must be found each year under national planning guidelines to satisfy demand.

However, he has insisted several modifications must first be enacted before the Local Plan is considered for adoption, which could happen at a full council meeting on Thursday, July 30.

Despite the setback, Fellgate campaigners insist their fight is far from finished and will continue to rally support.

However, some concede their hopes may rest on developers balking at the financial cost - including multi-million-pound infrastructure improvements – and pulling out.

Long-term opponent, Cllr Geraldine Kilgour, who plans to vote against the Local Plan, said: “I’m absolutely devastated. It’s not what we hoped for and not what Green Belt designation deserves.

Cllr Geraldine Kilgour has opposed the development.placeholder image
Cllr Geraldine Kilgour has opposed the development. | IconicMedia

“The Green Belt wasn’t in the Local Plan for years and then it suddenly appears. If it wasn’t in the first place, it shouldn’t be in now.

“But this is not done yet. I’m hoping this plan is not viable.

“The developers are going to have to pay to build local services and a primary school – it looks like the inspector is going to hold them to account.

“I do think that possibly the only hope is that it’s too much or someone says it’s not on solid ground. We can’t financially do a judicial review.

“I do think the inspector has been fair with his main modifications, but the council presented him with a fait accompli.

“I still had hope and still do, but it’s not the news we wanted. It’s not over but it is a major setback.”

Dave Green, spokesman for the Save the Fellgate Green Belt Working Group, added: “This certainly isn’t the outcome that we have fought for over the past two-and-a-half years.

“We are well supported throughout South Tyneside, and I believe many residents will contact their councillors.

“Please rest assured that our campaign will continue to highlight the need to save the Fellgate Green Belt for as long as it takes.”

In his report, Mr Spencer ruled the benefits of the Fellgate project “outweigh the harms”, finding also that council chiefs have “left no stone unturned” in their bid to find alternative sites.

He added it was “crucial” to recognise that Fellgate represents an important opportunity to demonstrate that “strategic Green Belt release” can “yield significant benefits”.

Inspector’s report outlines £40m improvement works

Independent government inspector David Spencer held two public consultations into South Tyneside Council’s Local Plan strategy document, following it twice being rejected by councillors.

In his report, he concluded Local Plan “provides an appropriate basis” for strategic development, provided several ‘main modifications’ are made.

These include various amendments to the policy for the Fellgate plan to enable timely delivery and reflect updated infrastructure evidence.

He found £40m of infrastructure improvements were needed on roads near the estate, including at the Whitemare Pool roundabout.

His report states this burden must fall on developers but that improvements can be made “incrementally”.

Campaigners believe housebuilders will not pay up and will instead leave the council to fork out upfront costs that they will later reclaim, leaving taxpayers on the hook.

Mr Spencer also wants a separate strategic policy for the proposed Town End Farm housing allocation to reflect its scale and significance.

It should address specific delivery issues for the site and provide clarity on site specific matters.

He also wants the council to re-profile its housing trajectory to reflect updated land availability evidence and to 'step' the housing requirement to ensure a deliverable supply on plan adoption.

In regard to campaigners' concerns that the sewerage network cannot cope with increased housing, he is demanding further clarity on disposal of foul water.

Mr Spencer has also called for an increase in the affordable housing requirement for East Boldon.

And he wants other modifications to ensure that the plan is positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

But his report has struck a blow against owners who stable their horses at West Fellgate Farm, where land is also earmarked for housing.

His report says he has applied only “negligible weight” to their concerns and that the livery facility is a private enterprise whose owner can do as it pleases.

In agreeing to allow Green Belt development, Mr Spencer found the borough’s main urban areas of South Shields, Jarrow and Hebburn, cannot meet all the development needs “by a large margin”.

South Tyneside Council has said his findings represent ‘a major step forward’ and that he had found the Local Plan ‘provides a suitable framework for guiding future development’.

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice