South Shields motorist caught drink driving just weeks into a 40-month ban

A South Tyneside motoring menace who drove while drunk just three weeks into a 40-month ban has been spared jail by a judge who said her hands were tied.

District Judge Zoe Passfield told Paul McKay, 47, of Milton Street, Chichester, South Shields, his habitual offending was so serious it demanded an immediate prison term.

But she said imposing that would be unfair, after borough magistrates at McKay’s initial hearing in June said they did not think his latest crimes merited that.

Standing before them, he pleaded guilty to charges of drink driving, driving while disqualified and driving without insurance.

They deferred sentence so he could work on his rehabilitation with the Probation Service – and he had engaged well, South Tyneside Magistrates’ Court heard.

South Tyneside Magistrates' Courtplaceholder image
South Tyneside Magistrates' Court | National World

McKay, a mechanic, returned to the same court on Tuesday, December 2, to be sentenced for those matters.

Judge Passfield appeared to express surprise when told by defence solicitor David Forrester of the decision made by the previous court.

Sentencing McKay to a 16-week suspended prison term, she said it was her view “it should be an immediate custodial sentence” but “ your sentence was deferred”.

Judge Passfied added: “Because you have complied with that, I don’t think I can impose that immediate period of imprisonment.”

The court heard McKay was convicted of drink driving and banned in April, receiving a suspended 12-week sentence.

He was caught drug driving a month later and a community order was imposed to run alongside, along with a 40-month driving disqualification.

His latest offence came on Tuesday, June 3, when he was pulled over by police as he drove a blue Ford Fiesta in Dean Road, South Shields, prosecutor Jonathan Moore said.

A breath test showed he was over the limit for alcohol, giving a reading in breath of 57mcg, against a legal limit of 35mcg.

Roadside checks also showed he was driving without insurance and while disqualified.

Mr Moore added: “Police saw a blue Fiesta driving towards them, and they followed it.

“It took a corner erratically and they stopped the vehicle. He smelled of alcohol.”

David Forrester, defending, said: “The bench deferred sentence for him to comply with the Probation Service and that he commits no further offence.

“They took a leap of faith with him because his offences were such that the bench could have suspended sentence straight away.

“They were perhaps swayed by a letter from an employer, which maybe made the bench give him the opportunity.,

“I think the magistrates were more than fair to give him that opportunity. He’s done his best to take up that opportunity.”

Judge Passfield jailed McKay for 10 weeks for driving while disqualified and to four concurrent weeks for drink driving, suspended for 12 weeks.

She also jailed him for six consecutive weeks for breaching his community order and extended his existing suspended sentence by six months, to 18 months.

McKay was also banned from driving afresh for 40 months and must complete 180 hours of unpaid work and pay a £154 victim surcharge and £85 court costs.

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice