Five questions for Primrose councillor Alex Barr after he quit South Tyneside Reform UK group
The Shields Gazette has obtained a letter sent to Cllr Alex Barr after he quit Reform UK to sit as an independent councillor.
South Tyneside Labour leader Geraldine Kilgour has demanded answers over Cllr Alex Barr’s shock departure from the Reform UK group just months after being elected.


Cllr Kilgour has written to both Cllr Barr and South Tyneside Council leader Paul Mackings after it was announced the Primrose councillor had “voluntarily resigned” from the Reform UK group and would now sit as an independent.
Her letter sets out five key questions over why Cllr Barr quit the group, whether he remains a Reform UK member and whether he intends to serve the rest of his four-year term as an independent councillor.
Here’s Cllr Kilgour letter in full:
Dear Councillor Barr,
I am writing to you following the statement issued by South Tyneside Reform UK that you have ‘voluntarily’ resigned from the South Tyneside Reform UK Group of Councillors.
I feel the residents of Primrose who elected you to serve a four-year term as their Councillor deserve some straight answers as to your actions.
1. Why have you resigned from the Reform UK Group? Is it a difference of opinion on the direction of the Council? What has changed since the May elections?
2. The statement advises you have resigned from the Reform UK Group, but makes no mention of your membership of Reform UK – are you still a member of Reform UK or have you resigned your membership?
3. Do you feel it acceptable to stand for election in Primrose as a Reform UK candidate and then two months later move your allegiances to Independent? What does this say about honesty, openness and transparency to the electorate?
4. There was a by-election in Harton on August 6th – what has happened since last week to make you resign from the Reform UK Group – or did you intentionally delay your resignation until after the by election in Harton?
5. Do you intend to serve your full term as a Councillor sitting as an Independent or will you be resigning your seat on the Council?
There are also legitimate questions about your availability. Commentators on Facebook allege that you work away from South Tyneside during the week and clearly the weekend is, quite rightly, reserved for time with your family. Is this why you have held no Councillors surgeries and serve on only the minimal number of Committees legally required in the Town Hall.
The residents of Primrose not only deserve but need a representative on the Council who will serve their interests with diligence, determination and commitment. Do you believe that you possess those qualifications required of a public servant?
Making yourself unavailable for comment to the media, and Reform UK advising they will issue no further statement on this shambles is not transparent or fair to the residents of Primrose.
The electors of Primrose deserve answers - the electors of Primrose deserve better.
Yours sincerely,
Geraldine Kilgour
Leader, South Tyneside Labour Group
