Cost to taxpayers revealed as South Tyneside Council civic car rules not always followed

Concerns have been raised around the use of the civic car by councillors – although officers stressed it is “not widespread”.

The latest meeting of South Tyneside Council’s audit committee received an update on a review which took place by the internal audit team on the framework in place around civic car use.

Historically civic drivers have maintained a record of all journeys made, recording, destinations, vehicle mileage and passenger details.

South Shields Town Hallplaceholder image
South Shields Town Hall | LDRS

A report from officers noted in 2024/25, excluding use by the mayor and deputy mayor, the civic car was used on 28 separate occasions by five different councillors.

These journeys resulted in £1,060 of costs being attributed to councillors which were all included in the published list of members’ travel expenses for 2024/25.

The report added: “Usage of the civic car by members outside of the mayor and deputy mayor is not widespread, as vehicles were used by only 5 other members on 28 separate occasions.”

The 2024 version of South Tyneside Council’s constitution, agreed in May 2024, indicates councillors “may benefit from the use of the civic car for travel”.

It also sets out an expectation when it is being used “a business case is made that the civic car will be a more cost-effective option than travelling by public transport or using private transport”.

Finally, it states “requests will be submitted to the budget holder and monitoring officer for authorisation, including a comparison of costs expected to be incurred per private travel and public transport”.

However the report from officers to the latest meeting of the audit committee noted “developing and implementing new procedures which align with the updated constitution took longer than anticipated”.

It said therefore councillors and officers “continued to follow the previously agreed processes based around earlier versions of the constitution”.

It added: “Consequently throughout 2024/25 members were not submitting business cases, cost comparisons were not carried out and individual journeys in the civic car were not reviewed or authorised by the budget holder and monitoring officer.”

Officers concluded the control framework outlined in the revised constitution was “not fully complied with during 2024/25”.

However it is “understood that member support have now developed and implemented updated procedures to ensure that appropriate control measures are in place for 2025/26”.

Speaking at the meeting, Councillor Andrew Guy, South Tyneside Alliance Group representative, said the use of the civic car was something which “was concerning for many members”.

He added: “It does send the wrong message when you are making cuts, I think it absolutely sends the wrong message.

“It concerns assets that are effectively owned by the public purse.”

Cllr Guy also voiced worries that it wasn’t “detected and raised” that the latest procedures were not being followed.

Councillor Chris Davies, Green group representative and audit committee chair, added it is “quite concerning” that the previous constitutional change had not been implemented in a timely manner.

It comes as councillors on the constitution committee are to on Thursday (March 19) discuss proposed changes for 2026/27 which would bring updated expectations for use of the civic car.

This would include clearer cost transparency and new guidance on passenger arrangements.

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice