Latest on complaints against South Tyneside councillors after 'totally unreasonable' situation
Complaints about the conduct of South Tyneside’s councillors continue to drop and the local authority has made “really good progress” after previously having a “totally unreasonable” number of outstanding cases.
The latest meeting of South Tyneside Council’s standards committee heard there were currently 11 open complaints under the elected members’ code of conduct.
The panel was told eight complaints have been concluded and closed since December, with one new complaint submitted during this time.


Of the 11 open complaints against councillors, 10 are at the “formal investigation” stage, while one has seen a “complaint received with evidence”.
Council officers noted some of those are “a little bit historic” and “every complaint is different” and they “take their own journey”.
They added the aim is for formal investigations to be completed within six months, although they noted this “isn’t always the case”.
It comes as a standards committee hearing was recently held focusing on independent Cllr John Robertson who was found to have breached the council’s code of conduct following a complaint by senior local authority officers.
The overall number of complaints since recording started in January 2020 is now 330.
A report from local authority chiefs stressed “every effort is being made to process complaints quickly, and specifically to conclude formal investigations”.
Speaking at the meeting (on Monday, March 16), Lucy Keating, council director of legal and governance, said the local authority is making “really good progress” and the number of complaints “has seen a reduction” compared to previous years “which is positive.”
Council officers previously admitted South Tyneside had seen a “very, very high” number of complaints compared to neighbouring councils, as well as noting the resource implications of investigating such complaints.
Independent chair professor Grahame Wright, speaking at the latest meeting, stressed it takes a “huge amount of time” for officers to deal with complaints, which they must do alongside other parts of their job.
He added: “We’ve had so many outstanding cases in the last municipal year, the number of outstanding cases was just totally unreasonable.
“The message we need to get across is please don’t make trivial complaints, it costs us a fortune, and especially councillors, please do not make trivial complaints against other councillors.”
Officers noted “external investigators” have been appointed to carry out independent investigations against several complaints that have been referred for formal investigation.
Documents also noted where external investigators have been or are being used and appointed to conduct and report on formal investigations, the “costs of such appointments are in the region of £20,000 per investigation.”
Since the panel met in December there have been four requests by complainants for decisions to be reviewed.
Of the total 330 complaints against councillors received since January 2020, 173 complaints were from members of the public, 137 were from councillors, 11 were from officers and nine were from other individuals.
Of the cases which have been closed to date, around 70% were rejected by the monitoring officer, while just 3% have had to be closed after a hearing, a total of 10.
Recorded council data on complaints is anonymised unless the complaint is escalated to this formal hearing stage, where an investigating officer’s report outlines the context of the complaint, findings and recommended sanctions.