Major update on new six-bed HMO near South Tyneside District Hospital after locals and MP criticise plans

Plans for a new six-bedroom house in multiple occupation (HMO) in South Shields have been narrowly approved by councillors, despite objections from local councillors, local residents and the town’s MP.

South Tyneside Council’s Planning Committee, at a meeting this week, approved a planning application for 3 Loudon Street in the town’s Whiteleas ward.

Emma Lewell, MP for South Shieldsplaceholder image
Emma Lewell, MP for South Shields | Iconic Media

A planning application noted that work already started on the property in July, 2025, but had not been completed and floor plans showed six en-suite bedrooms across two floors, along with a utility area, kitchen/dining area and a living room.

A design, access and planning statement submitted with the HMO application noted that works “already commenced” under “permitted development rights” that were previously in place for HMOs, noting that the six-bed HMO did not need planning permission at the time works started.

Following South Tyneside Council’s recent decision to launch an “immediate” borough-wide Article 4 Direction removing such permitted development rights for small HMOs, the applicant submitted a planning bid for the Loudon Street property to “regularise the development.”

Applicants said that the proposed site was in a “highly sustainable location” near bus and Metro services and cycling infrastructure, supporting “car-free” or “low-car” living, and that bedrooms and communal facilities would “significantly exceed the space standards” set out in council guidance.

It was noted that the existing garage to the south would be converted to create a “spacious sixth bedroom” and that the “development is designed to deliver a premium living environment, aiming for a finish comparable to high-end hospitality standards”.

Developers said that to “support modern professional living (including working from home), each room is equipped with a dedicated working desk, TV, and hardwired data points for superfast broadband” and that private en-suites would ” reduce reliance on shared facilities”.

The design, access and planning statement added “a primary driver for this application is the specific demand from local key workers and professionals who require high-quality, flexible accommodation near their place of work [and] the site is uniquely positioned to serve one of the borough’s largest employment hubs”.

In the context of the site’s close proximity to South Tyneside District Hospital, developers added there was a “well-documented demand for high-standard rental accommodation for rotating junior doctors, nursing staff, and healthcare professionals who work irregular shifts and require proximity to the hospital without the financial burden of maintaining a full single-household property.”

South Tyneside Council’s planning department, in a report published ahead of a decision-making Planning Committee this week, had recommended the HMO plan for approval.

It was noted that the “greatest weight in deciding this application needs to be given to the NPPF [national planning policy framework] as opposed to local planning policy, given that the application includes housing development and the council’s housing land supply/delivery deficiencies”.

Council planners, in the committee report, said the development would “bring a currently vacant building back into use” and would “provide a form of affordable accommodation that meets an identified housing need”, with no “significant harm or adverse impacts […] identified in respect of visual and residential amenity, biodiversity, highway safety, or in respect of crime/antisocial behaviour/fear of crime and flood risk/drainage.”

During a council public consultation exercise on the plan there were around 28 objections raising a range of concerns, including the “cumulative impact” of HMOs in the area, increased noise, traffic issues and concerns about management of the property, as well as the development changing the character of the area.

There were also objections from Whiteleas ward councillors Robin Coombes and Ken Dawes, with Cllr Dawes requesting a referral to the Planning Committee, and an objection from South Shields MP Emma Lewell.

A statement from the South Shields MP, included in a council committee report, raised concerns about the development “resulting in the permanent loss of a spacious family home on a quiet residential cul-de-sac, near to local schools and amenities”.

It was also noted that Loudon Street, as a small cul-de-sac, could face “significant issues with parking” and that “additional residents could increase the amount of foot traffic and visitors, and increase the potential of antisocial behaviour and disruption.”

Arguments for and against the proposals were put forward at a crunch meeting at South Shields Town Hall on February 9, 2026.

A number of objectors spoke at the meeting raising concerns about the development, including a local resident and Cllr Ken Dawes, followed by questions and comments from members of the Planning Committee.

Cllr Dawes raised concerns about impacts on the “nice quiet little street” in terms of parking pressures and access issues linked to the new HMO, as well as noting the lack of streetlights in the street and asking how “community cohesion and safety would be fulfilled.”

Meanwhile, the public objector raised concerns about “harmful impacts on the character, safety and amenity of Loudon Street”, as well as commenting on the “over concentration” of HMOs and the “cumulative impact” and highway safety issues from additional vehicles.

The public objector said that the change of use HMO plan, and the increased intensity of use of the property, would “disrupt and destroy the heritage of the street” and added there was also a petition in opposition.

A statement read out on behalf of another public objector said the HMO proposal was “unsuitable for the area and will have a significant negative impact on the surrounding community”, including issues around increased parking demand, antisocial behaviour and access issues for vehicles.

A representative for the applicant also spoke at the meeting maintaining the HMO would not lead to an “overconcentration” of HMOs or “community harm” and said the HMO was “not speculative” and would be “well-managed”, with “generous communal space” and a layout designed to “reduce internal conflict”.

The applicant’s agent said that six residents would be comparable to a large family home and that the HMO was “not a transient scheme” and would “specifically suit professionals and key workers” given the site’s close distance to South Tyneside District Hospital.

It was also noted that the council’s licensing regime would give “ongoing oversight” of the HMO over the “lifetime of the use.”

Following questions from Planning Committee member councillor David Kennedy about the shared responsibility of the maintenance of the unadopted road at Loudon Street, it was noted this was not a planning matter and would be a matter for the relevant landowners.

Councillor Kate Owens-Palmer acknowledged that the plans presented a “high-quality HMO” in terms of the accommodation and communal space which “if well-managed may well attract the type of resident that the developer is hoping for”, but still raised concerns about the development “changing the character of the area.”

Councillor Paul Brenen, who opposed the development, said he had concerns about parking issues on the “very small and narrow street” in a “close-knit area” and said that the HMO would “cause problems” and “change the character” of the area.

Councillor Chris Davies said the development had “good sized rooms and good communal space” and acknowledged the challenges around requirements to maintain the unadopted road, urging developers to ensure they are “paying their share”.

On the principle of HMO development, given its proximity to the hospital and the standard of accommodation proposed, Cllr Davies said he would support the proposal.

Councillor Shirley Ford, who also backed calls to approve the plans, said she “felt torn” and “understood residents’ concerns” about parking, the character of the area and wider HMO concerns but said the material planning considerations needed to reject the plans were “not at all as strong as the previous [HMO] planning applications” discussed at the meeting.

Councillor Lynne Proudlock, who also supported the plans, noted the proposed development’s close proximity to South Tyneside District Hospital and said the “quality of the work is very good.”

Council planners noted that there were no highway objections to the HMO plan and that the site would have “similar levels of parking requirement” as the existing house.

After being put to the vote, the plans were approved by a narrow majority vote, with a majority of councillors deciding to approve the HMO plan in line with the recommendation of council officers.

The committee vote included five votes in favour, four votes against and one abstention.

For more information on the HMO plan visit South Tyneside Council’s planning portal website and search reference: 250751

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice