South Tyneside councillors use first-class travel 'frequently' and it's costing taxpayers thousands

First class travel was utilised on more than 50 occasions by councillors in South Tyneside over the last year at a total cost of around £10,100, according to a local authority report.

The latest meeting of South Tyneside Council’s audit committee received an update on a review which took place by the internal audit team around councillors’ travel.

The report noted in 2024/25 members travel costs totalled £17,967 and testing on the completeness and accuracy of the data noted “no significant issues”.

South Shields Town Hallplaceholder image
South Shields Town Hall | LDRS

This included net costs of approximately £11,900 on rail, air travel and personal mileage associated with attending training courses, conferences and other events.

There were 14 councillors who attended such events during 2024/25, attending some 35 events, conferences or training sessions.

As several were attended by more than one councillor, overall there were 63 individual instances of members logging their travels, with the average cost per trip “around £200”.

The council’s constitution states “all members will normally travel standard, but the council will seek to secure cost-effective travel arrangements at all times”.

It adds “first-class travel is not an automatic right and will never be appropriate for a short journey. There must be real justification as to why a councillor would ever travel first class”.

The report from officers stated the review found first class travel was utilised on 53 occasions at a cost of around £10,100, with standard class travel used six times at a cost of around £600.

There was one occasion where a personal vehicle was used, costing £197, while there were six occasions when attendance at a conference or event involved a flight, with the approximate cost of flights £1,000.

Officers noted that councillors are required to complete a members conference attendance form for such travels.

These are approved by the appropriate political group leader, signed by the budget holder/monitoring officer and authorised by the cabinet member for governance and resources.

In reviewing the completed forms officers said it “was apparent that during 2024/25, older versions of the form had on occasion been used”.

They noted these older versions “do not incorporate the section which requires the member to complete a clear rationale to support proposed first-class travel, hence the need for first class travel on these occasions was not well explained”.

Both forms incorporate a box which is ‘ticked’ to show the member’s preference to travel first-class and officers noted this “indicates that first-class travel is (under certain circumstances) permissible”.

A review of the completed forms noted when seeking first class travel, a number of members cited ‘health issues’, which they advised required them to “have seating with additional legroom”.

Officers noted the details of medical issues were not questioned by internal audit, but it is “appreciated there are medical circumstances when additional space may be necessary”.

They also stated there were occasions, such as making late bookings, when “limited seating availability and the need for members to sit together to hold discussions” were listed as reasons necessitating first-class travel.

The review report said “facilitating members sitting together to discuss issues on longer journeys could in some limited circumstances be seen as not unreasonable”.

Officers noted the constitution “does not expressly preclude using first class travel” and their findings indicated “that there are circumstances when first class travel is permissible”.

They also noted “anecdotally, utilising first-class travel is not always significantly more expensive than alternate travel options” and where possible railcards are used and advanced booking carried out to “seek value”.

Their report summarised: “Travel outside the borough to conferences, seminars, training etc. is not extensive and the costs involved are not considered significant in the context of having members who are suitably trained and informed.

“The review has highlighted that premium travel modes were frequently utilised during 2024/25 and has noted that the rationale behind members’ choices is not always well explained.

“However, it is appreciated that health needs, seating availability and costs will all be considerations.”

Councillor Andrew Guy, South Tyneside Alliance Group representative, previously raised concerns around first class travel use, arguing “every pound spent on luxury travel is a pound not spent fixing damp homes, repairing roads, or supporting residents who actually need it”.

Speaking at the audit committee, he said: “The bit that for me that doesn’t sit right is the constitution does say that members should normally travel standard class.

“From an audit point of view I would like to say thank you for putting that report out there.”

Green group Councillor Chris Davies, audit committee chair, highlighted how the report comes amid a backdrop of difficult financial challenges which are impacting residents.

He said: “We are here to deliver value for money and we are experiencing significant budgetary pressures.”

Labour’s Councillor Ken Dawes said audit has “done its job” and looked at the issue and “on paper no rules have been broken”.

It comes as councillors on the constitution committee are to on Thursday (March 19) discuss travel policy changes for 2026/27 which would require members to use the cheapest fare for rail travel.

If adopted, this would mean first‑class would only be permitted only if it’s the cheapest or if councillors pay the difference themselves.

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice