Verdict delivered on HMO conversion scheme for family home in 'tight-knit' South Shields street

Plans for a new six-bedroom house in multiple occupation (HMO) in a South Shields neighbourhood have been rejected by councillors.

South Tyneside Council’s Planning Committee, at a meeting this week, refused an application for 3-4 Belle Vue Crescent in the town’s Biddick and All Saints ward.

General view of Belle Vue Crescent, South Shieldsplaceholder image
General view of Belle Vue Crescent, South Shields | Google/LDRS

Proposed floor plans showed six bedrooms across three levels, each with an en-suite bathroom and “kitchenette”, as well as a communal kitchen area serving the wider HMO.

A design, access and planning statement submitted with the HMO application noted that works “already commenced” on site in early-October, 2025, under “permitted development rights” that were in place, meaning the six-bed HMO did not need planning permission at that time.

Following South Tyneside Council’s decision to launch an “immediate” borough-wide Article 4 Direction removing such permitted development rights for HMOs, the applicant submitted a planning bid for the Belle Vue Crescent property to “regularise the development.”

Applicants said that the proposed site was in a “highly sustainable location with excellent public transport links”, suited for “car-free” or “low-car” living, and that en-suite bedrooms and communal facilities “exceed the space standards” expected by the council.

It was also noted that the “existing garage to the rear is to be converted to create a spacious sixth bedroom” and that “minor external alterations to the rear include replacing the existing garage doors with windows, relocating the rear door, and blocking up an existing door”.

Developers said the “proposed development retains the building’s existing aesthetics on the front facade facing Belle Vue Crescent” and would “maintain the existing street scene and character of the area, addressing a primary concern of the Article 4 Direction regarding visual impact.”

The design, access and planning statement added that “small HMOs provide a vital source of affordable accommodation for young professionals and key workers” and that the “site is located in a mixed-use area near Stanhope Road, where higher-density living is appropriate and supported by infrastructure.”

South Tyneside Council’s planning department, in a report published ahead of a decision-making Planning Committee this week, had recommended the HMO for approval.

Council planners said the “greatest weight in deciding this application needs to be given to the NPPF [national planning policy framework] as opposed to local planning policy, given that the application includes housing development and the council’s housing land supply/delivery deficiencies”.

It was noted that the proposal would “provide a form of affordable accommodation that meets an identified housing need” and that “no significant harm or adverse impacts have been identified in respect of visual and residential amenity, biodiversity, highway safety, or in respect of crime/antisocial behaviour/fear of crime and flood risk/drainage.”

During a council public consultation exercise on the plans there were around 10 objections received raising concerns ranging from “impact on local character and community” in terms of increased noise, as well as parking pressures, including to an adjacent dental surgery, waste management and more.

There were also concerns raised linked to the proximity of the proposed HMO to a nearby school SS Peter & Paul Catholic Primary School and pressures on local services.

Councillor Katharine Maxwell, Biddick and All Saints ward member, called the application into the Planning Committee for decision, and members of the panel discussed the application at South Shields Town Hall on February 9, 2026.

Councillor Joan Hamilton raised concerns about the number of “safeguards” recommended by the council’s community safety team, outlined in a council committee report, and asked if it reflected existing antisocial behaviour issues in the area.

Council planners, responding, said there were no specific issues raised and that the community safety comments were general and linked to the management of the HMO which would be regulated via the council’s HMO licensing regime, via environmental health.

Councillor Chris Davies noted there were antisocial behaviour issues in the area, raised concerns about parking issues linked to the proposed HMO given the street is a cul-de-sac and noted residents’ concerns around the “change to the character of the place” from existing HMO developments.

Cllr Davies also asked if a condition could be added to reduce the occupancy of the proposed HMO from six occupants to five occupants to allow for improved communal space, however council planners said this would not be possible.

Elsewhere, councillor David Kennedy said there was a “danger of an over concentration [of HMOs] in this area” and raised concerns about parking and access issues linked to the proposed site for the HMO.

Councillor Paul Brenen also raised concerns about the “cumulative impact” of HMOs in the area, as well as criticising parking and noting the HMO would impact the amenity of residents in a “tight-knit street”.

The councillor noted the borough-wide Article 4 Direction brought in by South Tyneside Council aimed to give the Planning Committee “a greater say and greater control on where we’re going to put these HMOs”.

“As far as I can see they’re targeting family homes in community areas with a community identity and these HMOs change that identity of the local area,” Cllr Brenen added.

“This committee is here to defend local people’s opinions and it’s basically the only option we’ve got to stop HMOs.”

Councillor Shirley Ford also raised concerns about the cumulative impact of the new HMO, given existing and proposed HMOs in the area.

Cllr Ford said there would be an impact on residential amenity and the character of terraced streets and issues for future HMO residents, given the “lack of communal space within the [HMO] design.”

Council planners, responding to councillors’ concerns, said the HMO had a communal kitchen area as well as a rear yard and noted views from the council’s highways authority that there were “no objections to zero in-curtilage car parking provision with residents utilising off-site car parking opportunities”.

On parking matters, it was also noted that there was existing car parking in the area and a car park behind the site.

After being put to the vote councillors voted unanimously to refuse the HMO application, against the advice of council planning officers who had recommended approval.

Reasons for refusal cited by the Planning Committee included the HMO’s impact on residential amenity, impact on the character of the area and the cumulative impact linked to the new HMO, given existing HMOs in the area.

The applicant has the right to challenge the council’s refusal decision by lodging an appeal with the Secretary of State.

For more information on the HMO plan, visit the council’s planning portal website and search reference: 250739

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice