Legal challenge over ‘failure to investigate’ Dominic Cummings' North East trips rejected by High Court

A legal challenge over the decision not to investigate Dominic Cummings for alleged breaches of coronavirus lockdown rules has been rejected by the High Court.

At an extraordinary press conference in Downing Street’s Rose Garden in May, Boris Johnson’s senior aide argued that his journey to Durham was to protect his family’s health, while a drive to Barnard Castle 25 miles was to test his eyesight.

Mr Cummings said his actions were “reasonable in these circumstances”, adding: “I don’t regret what I did.”

Senior aide to the Prime Minister Dominic Cummings in Downing Street, London. Photo by PA.

Durham Constabulary later said officers had concluded “there might have been a minor breach of the regulations that would have warranted police intervention”, but did not intend to take “retrospective action”.

At a hearing in London today, Tuesday, November 3, Michael Mansfield QC referred to “evidence of the ‘Cummings effect’ reducing public trust or compliance”, as well as the “Cummings defence” of people “seeking to justify breaching the law”, as demonstrating “the ongoing public sore arising from this issue”.

Duncan Atkinson QC, for the DPP, argued there had been no decision by the DPP not to prosecute or to not refer the matter to police, and that Mr Redston should be refused permission.

The court’s decision for refusing permission would be provided in writing by Thursday afternoon.

Speaking outside court, Mr Redston said: “I’m obviously very disappointed, as you can imagine, but ultimately the aim of this is to ensure Dominic Cummings is actually prosecuted for the breach of lockdown regulations.”

He added: “I think we are in the position we are as a nation to some extent because of what Cummings did.

“The Prime Minister said ‘stay at home’, those are his words.”

You can subscribe to this website and enjoy unlimited access to local news, information and puzzles online. With a digital subscription, you can read more than 5 articles, see fewer ads, enjoy faster load times, and get access to exclusive newsletters and content. Simply click ‘Subscribe’ in the menu.