'Reject the proposal' - Emma Lewell backs fight against Harton petrol station plan

MP Emma Lewell has added her words to the fight against a Harton petrol station plan, which would demolish a part of the town’s history.

Campaigners fighting a plan to expand a South Tyneside petrol station by demolishing a prominent Victorian landmark next door have won top town-level political backing.

Emma Lewell MP has been having her say on the proposed plans for a Harton development.placeholder image
Emma Lewell MP has been having her say on the proposed plans for a Harton development. | Canva

South Shields MP Emma Lewell has stepped into the fray by urging planning chiefs to reject a proposal to knock down historic Harton Hall Cottages, at Harton village.

She has made her opposition known in a hard-hitting letter, in which she states modernisation must not be made by needlessly eradicating the past.

MP calls for ‘preserve and repurpose’

Instead of demolition, she believes the garage’s owner should try to ‘preserve and repurpose’ the buildings into any future scheme.

Ms Lewell's opposition coincides with a protest petition, created by village shop owner Barbara Compton, 67, topping 1,030 signatures.

Her intervention follows forecourt operator SRJ Energy Limited submitting a planning application to upgrade the Esso fuel stop and convenience store in Moor Lane.

The Houghton-le-Spring firm wants to bulldoze the two-story cottages, which it owns, and incorporate the site into its planned operations.

In her letter, Ms Lewell writes: ‘Harton Hall Cottages, dated 1878, have been culturally recognised and locally listed by South Tyneside Council, and they are an important part of South Shields’ architectural and social history.

‘These cottages were homes to the coachmen and gardener of Joseph Mason Moore, prominent former owner of Harton Hall, which recently received blue plaque status in recognition of its cultural importance.

‘This status further emphasises their value and significance to the town.

‘An integral part of Harton Village’s history’

‘They form an integral part of Harton Village’s history and cannot be replaced if they are lost to development.’

She adds: “I understand that development is critically important to the future of towns and villages, but wherever possible, progress should never come to the detriment of our town’s heritage and character.

‘It would be preferable if developers who actively acquire historical buildings of significant placement could invest in their preservation and repurposing, rather than in demolition.

‘I urge the council to reject the proposal, and any subsequent applications that intend to demolish these cottages.’

Ms Lewell’s opposition was welcomed by retailer Barbara, who believes her fast-growing online petition is a clear indication of the strength of feeling among locals.

She said: “I'm pleased that Emma supports this building being saved. I’m amazed that someone with her power locally would get involved.

“I had read in the Gazette that she was calling for historic buildings to be preserved, and that made me think I should contact her about the cottages.

“It’s quite wonderful that she has become involved and I hope her intervention helps.”

The cottages were part of Harton Hall, built by Mr Moore, a wealthy former town mayor, which still stands on one corner of the village’s traffic lights crossroads.

A heritage assessment submitted on behalf of SRJ Energy Limited has recorded the demolition as being of only ‘moderate’ significance and loss as causing ‘less than substantial harm’.

It states ‘the demolition of the cottages may be supportable in heritage terms’ and that a detailed historic recording would be needed.

This would be to mitigate ‘to a certain extent the harm which would evidently result from the loss of this non-designated heritage asset’.’

SRJ Energy Limited has not responded to requests for comment.

Barbara’s petition can be found at www.change.org

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice