"Significant harm" - Controversial HMO is rejected by South Tyneside Council after more than 1,300 objections
Hebburn HMO is rejected after petition opposing the six-bedroom plan received more than 1,300 signatures.
Controversial plans for a six-bedroom HMO in Hebburn, which sparked hundreds of public objections, have been officially refused by councillors.


South Tyneside Council's planning committee this week blocked plans seeking permission to convert a property at 13 Hall Road into a six-person house in multiple occupation (HMO).
Applicant Thunderstruck Properties Ltd lodged an application with the local authority last year for the HMO, with a supporting planning statement noting the scheme would provide an "appropriate standard of accommodation".
Initial plans proposed a seven-bed HMO but this was later reduced to six bedrooms during the planning process, with the final development including cycle parking, a communal kitchen and living area and the majority of bedrooms having en-suite facilities.
The application falls against a backdrop of South Tyneside Council’s decision last year to launch an “immediate” borough-wide Article 4 Direction removing permitted development rights for small HMOs, meaning that planning permission is now needed for all HMOs across the borough.
A submitted planning application from company Thunderstruck Properties Ltd stated work on the Hall Road HMO conversion started in November 2025 but has not been completed.
During council consultations, the HMO plans have sparked significant public opposition with around 144 objections submitted to the original seven-bed HMO and around 84 objections submitted to the revised six-bed HMO.
Concerns raised by objectors ranged from parking pressures and impacts on the character of the area and a local conservation area, to waste management, loss of privacy, the loss of a family home from the local housing market and more.
There was also an online petition against the HMO, which at the time of the planning committee on Tuesday, had nearly reached 1,300 signatures.
South Tyneside Council's planning department, in a report published ahead of the decision-making meeting this week, had recommended the HMO plan for approval.
It was noted that given the council's "housing land supply/delivery deficiencies", the "greatest weight in deciding this application" needed to be given to national planning policy, as opposed to local planning policy.
It was argued that the HMO would "provide social and economic gains by contributing to reducing the current shortfall in terms of housing supply and providing a form of affordable accommodation that meets an identified housing need", as well as "bringing a currently vacant building back into use".
Council planners added that there were "no identified adverse impacts arising from the proposal that would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits of the development."
The plans were formally debated at a meeting of the planning committee at South Shields Town Hall on June 23 and a number of members of the public spoke against the plans.
Councillors discussed issues raised by objectors, which included impacts on the character of the area, the loss of a family dwelling, noise and disturbance impacts on neighbouring properties, parking concerns and more.
Following lengthy discussions, a formal proposal was launched to reject the plans, against the recommendation of council planning officers to approve, and the refusal motion received backing from a majority of councillors.
Councillor Shirley Ford, launching the motion, said the reasons for refusal included the "harm to the character of the area", which was a "settled family area with a quiet character".
Cllr Ford noted that the proposed HMO plan would impact the "residential amenity of the existing residents", along with impacts on "community cohesion."
"Clearly that is the essence of the nature of the significant harm that would be brought about by this application," she added.
The applicant has the right to challenge the council's refusal decision by lodging an appeal with the Secretary of State.
For more information, visit the council's planning portal website and search for reference 250773.