Planners decide fate of new shared house in Jarrow that led to 1,312-signature petition
Plans for a new eight-bedroom house in multiple occupation (HMO) in South Tyneside have been refused following huge public opposition, including a 1,312-signature petition.
South Tyneside Council’s planning department has blocked an application to change the use of 12 Surrey Street near West Park in the Jarrow area.


Proposals also included a ground floor communal kitchen/dining area and amenity area and a cycle storage area in garage space.
Those behind the HMO scheme noted the building was in an “established residential area” and had been used as a “three-bedroom house”.
A planning statement submitted to council officials listed external alterations as part of the plans, including the “removal of the existing, poor-quality rear conservatory and the replacement of poor-quality windows and doors to the rear ground floor openings of the property with new uPVC units”.
Developers added that each HMO bedroom would be “provided with a self-contained en-suite, ensuring a high standard of privacy and amenity for occupants” and that “the internal circulation layout has been retained wherever possible, with new routes introduced to the loft space designed for efficient movement throughout the building.”
It was also noted that the site “benefits from a variety of public green spaces within close proximity” and also “enjoys excellent transport connectivity” in terms of public transport links.
During the planning application process, amended plans were received “moving the proposed bin storage area from the front yard area into the garage following comments from the transport development officer,” council planning documents state.
A council consultation exercise on the plans also sparked significant public opposition, which a council report described as “90 letters of objection” and a single petition “objecting to the development” with “1,312 signatures at the time of writing.”
Public concerns summarised in a council report ranged from increased crime and safety implications, waste storage and loss of privacy, to parking impacts, noise and disturbance, “strain on local services”, devaluation of neighbouring properties, “overcrowding of the dwelling” and more.
Councillor Geraldine Kilgour also called the planning application into the Planning Committee for decision, if planning officers were minded to recommend approval, and raised concerns about “the level of occupancy and its potential impact on the amenity of the area.”
After considering the planning application and assessing it against planning policies, South Tyneside Council’s planning officers ruled on the application under “delegated powers.”
The planning application did not go before South Tyneside Council’s most recent Planning Committee but was refused the same day on January 12, 2026.
Council planners, in a decision report published on the council’s planning portal website, listed two main reasons for refusal.
It was noted that the “application property is situated in a locality comprised of predominantly single household family housing”.
In this context and with reference to the “close proximity of the application property to neighbouring dwellings”, council planners said the “increased comings and goings from residents, visitors and deliveries and the increased level of activity within the application site itself arising from the intensity of this large HMO use would be harmful to the residential amenity of neighbouring occupiers and the character and nature of the locality.”
The second reason for refusal referenced the “intensity of the residential use proposed”, which council planners said “would give rise to a poor-quality residential environment”.
This included “poor outlook and inadequate natural light for the occupiers of bedrooms 7 and 8 in the loft space and a lack of privacy and noise pollution in respect of those occupying bedroom 2 on the ground floor given its close proximity to the shared kitchen and outlook over the rear curtilage amenity space area.”
Comments from council planners elsewhere in the report said that there was “no substantive evidence that the proposed development would result in an increase of crime and antisocial behaviour in the area sufficient to warrant a refusal of this application”.
However, in terms of the principle of the development they added the proposal would “materially change the existing character of this particular property on the street of which it forms a part” and would “in turn […] have an unacceptable adverse impact on the living conditions of the proposed and surrounding local residents”.
The council decision report adds: “The proposal would make a positive contribution to housing delivery and supply with associated social and economic benefits during the period of construction and once the rooms are occupied.
“However, the contribution of such HMO accommodation to meeting housing need in South Tyneside through a more efficient use of land in an urban area and the associated benefits are limited by the scale of development proposed.
“The proposal is not considered to have a detrimental impact in terms of visual amenity, ecological impacts, or in terms of crime and antisocial behaviour.
“It is nevertheless considered that the proposed development would result in the intensification of use of the property to the detriment of the amenity of both the proposed and neighbouring occupiers and the character of the area, bearing in mind that the surrounding locality is an area of predominantly single household family housing, the close proximity of the application property to neighbouring properties and the poor living conditions provided for in respect of bedrooms 2, 7 and 8. This would be contrary to [planning policies].
“In the particular circumstances of this case, it is considered that these adverse impacts would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits when assessed against the policies of the NPPF [National Planning Policy Framework] as a whole.”
The applicant has the right to challenge the council’s refusal ruling by lodging an appeal with the Secretary of State.
For more information on the plan and council decision, visit South Tyneside Council’s planning portal website and search reference: 250708
For the latest public notices from your area, please visit: https://publicnoticeportal.uk/