Moise Kean scored his first Toffees goal in the opening 45 before Dominic Calvert-Lewin netted his third goal in two games against United. With the game all but dead, Florian Lejeune popped up with two goals to share the spoils.
But how did individuals perform? Here’s Miles Starforth’s player ratings...

1. Martin Dubravka - 7
Went into the game having made 100 top-flight saves – and was kept busy at Goodison Park. | Getty Images Photo: Ian MacNicol

2. Isaac Hayden - 6
Fielded again as a makeshift right wing-back, started brightly before being pegged back. | Getty Images Photo: Gareth Copley

3. Federico Fernandez - 6
Stuck at it on a difficult night for United, tried to get United going forward. | Getty Images Photo: Alex Livesey
.jpg?crop=3:2&trim=&width=640)
4. Jamaal Lascelles - 6
Should have done better for Everton’s first goal, but lead the team to an extraordinary comeback. | Getty Images Photo: Ian MacNicol