A late, late positive cameo from substitute Jacob Murphy might well have worked his way into Steve Bruce’s thinking while Andy Carroll’s impact off the bench played its part.
Here’s who Liam Kennedy picked as out as the plus points and the not so good, with Jonjo Shelvey not scoring too high in the ratings...
5. Paul Dummett - 7
Defensively solid against some challenging Villa widemen and has also provided a delivery option from the left-hand side. Photo: LEE SMITH
6. Jonjo Shelvey -
His passing performance in the first 45 was one of the worst I've ever seen. Slightly better in the second but just not good enough for a player who is clearly one of the first on Bruce's teamsheet. Photo: STU FORSTER
7. Joe Willock - 6
Attempting to drop into pockets of space but has looked a little lost in the midfield in the opening 45 but pushed Newcastle on in the second. Consistency needs found, mind. Photo: Clive Brunskill
8. Isaac Hayden - 6
Not that comfortable out on the left of the three but has put plenty of work in to keep things tight down that side. With Willock was much more of a positive influence in the second 45. Photo: Pool