But here we are, Steve Bruce, in his first season, with a smiling Mike Ashley has guided Newcastle United to the competition’s last 16 – even if they made hard, dramatic work of it.
United needed an extra-time cracker from Allan Saint-Maximin to win it, having thrown away a two-goal lead. Here's how Miles Starforth rated the players...

5. Florian Lejeune - 6
Recalled to the starting XI and competed well for much of the game. | Getty Images Photo: Richard Heathcote
.jpg?crop=4:3&trim=&width=640)
6. Matt Ritchie - 5
Booed by home fans for his previous association with their rivals Swindon, conceded free-kick for Oxford’s first goal. | Getty Images Photo: Ian MacNicol

7. Nabil Bentaleb - 6
Neat and tidy on the ball for most of the game, looked sharper, fitter. | Getty Images Photo: Richard Heathcote

8. Matty Longstaff - 6
Got around the pitch and snapped into a series of tackles, didn’t stop running for 120 minutes. | Getty Images Photo: Catherine Ivill

