Newcastle United's FA Cup run predicted ahead of Aston Villa trip

Newcastle United are enduring a disappointing season so far, but could the FA Cup provide some refuge?

The Magpies’ 3-2 defeat at home to Brentford on Saturday was their third in a row in the Premier League and their fourth in five games across all competitions. Eddie Howe’s men now sit 12th in the table, 11 points adrift of the top four with 13 games to play.

Newcastle also crashed out of the EFL Cup with a 5-1 aggregate defeat in the semi-finals to Manchester City, and must navigate a playoff tie against Qarabag to keep their Champions League campaign alive.

But on Saturday, Newcastle travel to Aston Villa in the FA Cup. It’s a tough tie against a team that have established themselves as outside title contenders this season. However, these are the sort of games that can reignite a season.

So, can Newcastle win at Villa Park? And if so, how far can they go in this season’s FA Cup? To answer those questions, we’ve turned to X’s AI chatbot, Grok.

Fourth round: Aston Villa vs Newcastle United

Grok: Newcastle travel to Villa Park as a Premier League side with European commitments but strong underlying quality, especially in midfield, where Bruno Guimarães dominates with his composure, passing range, and ability to break up play. Their defensive unit, featuring high-rated centre-backs like Malick Thiaw and Sven Botman who excel in aerial duels and organisation, should handle Villa's attacking threats effectively on the road. In forward areas, Anthony Gordon's pace and directness make him a prime match-winner on counters, while Joelinton's versatility and physical presence add goals or assists from advanced roles. Aaron Ramsdale steps in and provides reliable goalkeeping to keep things tight. Aston Villa are competitive at home, but Newcastle have characters for big games, with wins over strong sides and a knack for grinding out results. Expect a narrow away victory, perhaps sealed by Gordon's speed or a Guimarães-inspired moment.

Prediction: Aston Villa 1-2 Newcastle United

Fifth round: Newcastle United vs Grimsby Town

Grok: Back at St James' Park for the fifth round, Newcastle's home strength—evident in high-scoring wins and solid defensive displays—sets up a comfortable progression against Grimsby Town. The Mariners have earned their "giant-killing experts" tagline this season, having already stunned Wolverhampton Wanderers 4-1 in the fourth round (hypothetically) and memorably knocked out Manchester United in the EFL Cup earlier on. At Blundell Park, Grimsby show heart and threat on the break, but at St. James' Park, Newcastle's superior quality and depth prove too much. Midfield control from Guimarães and Sandro Tonali will dictate tempo and limit Grimsby's moments, while centre-backs Thiaw and Botman neutralise aerial threats. Up front, Gordon's pace and finishing, alongside options like Woltemade, Wissa or Barnes, can exploit spaces for multiple goals. A clean-sheet win feels likely, with Ramsdale and the backline keeping Grimsby's cup magic at bay.

Prediction: Newcastle United 3-0 Grimsby Town

Quarter-final: Manchester City vs Newcastle United

Grok: In the quarter-finals, Newcastle would face a heavyweight in an away tie against one of the favourites. Their run to this stage would highlight tactical discipline and standout performers like Guimarães orchestrating from deep and Gordon threatening on transitions. Defensive solidity from Thiaw, Botman, and full-backs would aim to frustrate early, while Ramsdale’s shot-stopping keeps the score down. However, elite opposition's relentless quality, home dominance, and attacking depth often overwhelm in these ties—Man City's possession and creativity would create overloads. Newcastle might grab a goal through a counter or set piece, but fatigue from a busy schedule and the step-up in intensity could prove decisive. The campaign ends creditably here, providing valuable experience and momentum for the rest of the season for a club balancing multiple fronts. Another cup exit to Man City.

Prediction: Manchester City 3-1 Newcastle United

Your next Newcastle United read: Kieran Trippier defends Eddie Howe after NUFC's 3-2 defeat v Brentford