Newcastle United v Man City VAR controversy explained as ex-ref delivers clear verdict
Newcastle United latest news: Dermot Gallagher has given his view on a number of Newcastle United v Man City VAR controversies.
Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher has given his verdict on a number of controversial decisions during Newcastle United’s win over Manchester City on Saturday.
A brace from Harvey Barnes secured the Magpies a vital win, although there was plenty of controversy surrounding his winning goal. The Premier League released a statement on X explaining the decision on Saturday night and now Gallagher has given his expert view on the call.
Dermot Gallagher’s view on Newcastle United v Manchester City controversy
Manchester City felt aggrieved when Barnes’ winner was allowed to stand, despite hints of offside and protests for a foul on goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma. The Italian, who had made some smart saves earlier in the piece to deny both Barnes and Nick Woltemade from opening the scoring in the first half, felt that he was fouled by Barnes in the build-up to the goal.
His pleas were waved away by the referee and VAR saw no reason to intervene. A check to see if Bruno Guimaraes, whose header rattled the bar before falling to the feet of Barnes, was onside or not also passed without the goal being chalked off.
All of these checks took some time, around five minutes in all, but they ultimately came to the correct end decision according to Gallagher: “I think goal,” Gallagher said on Sky Sports Ref Watch.
“Three instances, isn't it? Is the player offside when it's first crossed in? No, he's not, because the player at the bottom screen [Dias] keeps him onside. That's the first check.
The Gazette has launched a new WhatsApp NUFC channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our NUFC WhatsApp channel.
“Second check, is it a foul on Donnarumma? I think not. I think, you know, we've talked about this all season, right from week one and I don't think this is a foul. And then, is Barnes offside for the third incident? Well, he's behind the ball and that's the key issue.
“It doesn't matter what players are in front of him because once you're behind the ball, you can't be offside and he's clearly behind the ball. So all three have to be checked. It takes a little bit of time, but I think the right net result.”
The visitors also believed that they should have been awarded a penalty in the first-half when Fabian Schar caught Phil Foden in the box after the England international had taken a shot. Once again, VAR checked the decision, but it was deemed that there was not enough contact by Schar on his opponent to overturn the call of no penalty and that Schar’s actions were due to his momentum and not a reckless challenge.
Asked for clarification on that decision, Gallagher said: “I think the end of that statement says no penalty because in the guidelines it’s does a player make a challenge, the player get a shot away, and then he's contacted?
“If it's reckless, it becomes a yellow card. Once it becomes a yellow card, he's going to have to get a penalty.
“But because it's not reckless, not deemed reckless, as they say, it's a consequence of his momentum. What I would say is this is going to split a lot of people.”
.jpg?width=96&crop=1:1,smart)