Much like when the sides met at St James’s Park in the Premier League, the match ended goalless with both teams struggling to create chances.
The game went straight to penalties where Nick Pope made three saves to see Newcastle through.
Here are the player ratings from the match...
13. Kieran Trippier - 7
On for Manquillo 65: A sloppy early touch aside, the right-back injected some much needed creativity going forward, especially following Almiron’s introduction. | Getty Images
14. Sven Botman - 6
Almost thwarted by a bouncing ball moments after his introduction but was otherwise rarely tested. Photo: LINDSEY PARNABY
15. Miguel Almiron - n/a
On for Anderson 78: Almost scored with his first touch only to be denied by Johnstone. Photo: David Cannon
16. Joe Willock - n/a
On for Shelvey 86: Got into a good position but couldn’t release the ball. Photo: David Cannon