Newcastle United player ratings v Sunderland: 'Weak' Nick Woltemade & 2/10 'complete waste' in derby defeat

Sunderland 1-0 Newcastle United player ratings: Here’s how Anthony Elanga, Anthony Gordon, Nick Woltemade and co fared at the Stadium of Light.

Newcastle United lost 1-0 to Sunderland at the Stadium of Light - here are the player ratings from the match.

Newcastle United striker Nick Woltemade scores an own goal to give Sunderland the lead. placeholder image
Newcastle United striker Nick Woltemade scores an own goal to give Sunderland the lead. | Getty Images

Eddie Howe made two changes to his side that drew 2-2 at Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League with Lewis Miley and Anthony Elanga coming into the side in place of Joelinton and Harvey Barnes. Miley heads into the game fresh from becoming Newcastle’s youngest ever Champions League goalscorer after coming off the bench to replace Joelinton in Leverkusen.

The Brazilian was forced off in the game with a groin issue but has been passed fit enough to be included on the bench. Nick Pope, Kieran Trippier, Sven Botman, Emil Krafth and William Osula remain out.

The Gazette has launched a new WhatsApp NUFC channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our NUFC WhatsApp channel.

The long-awaited return of the derby match in the Premier League got off to a cagey start with little goalmouth action in the first half. Dan Ballard had Sunderland’s best chance with a header wide from Granit Xhaka’s cross at the end of the first half while Newcastle never really threatened.

Dan Burn was forced off at the end of the half due to an injury in the only notable incident in the opening 45 minutes.

Sunderland took the lead within a minute of the restart as Nick Woltemade headed the ball into his own net from a Nordi Mukiele cross.

It took until after the hour mark for either side to register a shot on goal in the game with Bruno Guimaraes’ effort from distance comfortably caught by Robin Roefs. Newcastle pushed forward in search of an equaliser but Sunderland stood firm to hold onto their narrow lead heading into the closing stages.

Sunderland were able to hold out for the three points to move four clear of Newcastle in the table after 16 games. It also extends their unbeaten run against The Magpies in the top flight to 10 games - with Newcastle’s last win coming back in 2011.

Here are the Newcastle United player ratings from the match (half-time ratings available here)...

Aaron Ramsdale - 6

Played several searching balls forward but didn’t have a save to make until the 73rd minute when he parried Wilson Isidor’s angled effort around the post.

Tino Livramento - 6

Had a couple of heavy touches trying to bring the ball forward. Wasted a lot of energy making runs for passes that never found him.

Malick Thiaw - 6

Came close to putting the ball into his own net inside the opening quarter of an hour.

Dan Burn - 6

Battled well in the air to win several high balls. Took a heavy blow in the first half in a clash with Nordi Mukiele and was taken off shortly afterwards.

Lewis Hall - 6

Put under a lot of pressure but still showed some smart touches to withstand it.

Sandro Tonali - 5

Still looks a little off the pace at times but tried to get involved. Booked and substituted shortly after.

Bruno Guimaraes - 5

Unable to stamp his authority on the game. Forced a straightforward save from Robin Roefs in the second half with the first shot on target in the match.

Lewis Miley - 6

Came into the side in place of Joelinton. Made a good challenge to stop a Sunderland counterattack. Generally quite tidy on the ball but wasn’t helped by his teammates around him. Saw a shot blocked in the closing stages.

Anthony Elanga - 2

Overran the ball after getting into a promising position down the right. Not quite switched on at key moments and kept giving the ball away before being hooked. Completely wasted his big opportunity.

Anthony Gordon - 4

Conceded possession on a few occasions early. Was trying to make things happen down his side and forced a booking for Reinildo Mandava.

Nick Woltemade - 3

Got the ball at his feet in some decent areas but was let down by his final pass or touch. Had an absolute horror minute with his header finding his own goal. A weak performance all around from the German.

Substitutes

Fabian Schar - 6

On for Burn 41: Replaced the injured Burn before half-time. Solid and composed for the most part.

Harvey Barnes - 5

On for Gordon 59: Posed more a bit more of a threat as Newcastle pushed for an equaliser but didn’t get close to the penalty area.

Jacob Murphy - 6

On for Elanga 59: Put a couple of teasing crosses into the box but couldn’t pick out a teammate.

Joe Willock - 5

On for Tonali 59: Offered something different in midfield and brought some energy to the game when Newcastle needed it. Just couldn’t bring the passing or attacking quality The Magpies needed.

Yoane Wissa - n/a

On for Woltemade 75: Came close to getting his foot onto Jacob Murphy’s deflected cross

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice