Allan Saint-Maximin netted his first goal since arriving in the summer, then controversy kicked in with VAR, quite correctly, ruling Andy Carroll was on-side before flicking on for Jonjo Shelvey to seal at 2-0 win in South Yorkshire.
Who shone on the day and who didn’t? Here’s Miles Starforth's ratings from Bramall Lane.
9. Isaac Hayden - 7
Had to play a very disciplined game in midfield, protected the back four as best he could. Photo: Alex Pantling
10. Allan Saint-Maximin - 7
Scored his first goal, a very good header, after 665 minutes of Premier League football. Photo: Nigel Roddis
11. Andy Carroll - 6
Handed his first Newcastle start since December 2010, but didn’t get a chance, did a good job defensively. Photo: OLI SCARFF
12. Joelinton - 6
(Carroll, 72) Got the nod ahead to come on ahead of Gayle. Photo: Catherine Ivill