Sky Sports release footage revealing why Sunderland duo weren’t sent off v Newcastle United

Newcastle United latest news: Sky Sports Ref Watch have dissected two key incidents from Sunderland’s win over Newcastle United on Sunday.

Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher has given his verdict on a number of incidents during Sunday’s Wear-Tyne derby between Sunderland and Newcastle United.

Whilst the match, the first in the Premier League in almost a decade, was played with passion, there were few very controversial moments in a match of very few chances at either end that was settled by an own goal. For Newcastle United, though, Nick Woltemade’s goal meant that they tasted their first defeat to their fierce rivals in over a decade.

But could the tale of the day have been different had Sunderland been reduced to ten men? Well, there were two incidents that could have seen both Nordi Mukiele and Brian Brobbey sent off by referee Peter Bankes, with the latter escaping a second yellow card for a foul on Lewis Miley.

VAR protocols mean that the technology cannot get involved in a yellow card offence, even if it leads to a second yellow card and thus that decision was reliant on the on-field call by the referee. Brobbey escaped that without punishment.

Sky Sports’ Ref Watch verdict on Sunderland v Newcastle United incidents

Speaking about Brobbey’s challenge on Miley on Sky Sports’ Ref Watch, Gallagher said: “It's interesting. If you look at this, you see he lands on his foot. Is it a second yellow card? Possibly. VAR can't get involved. But this is the referee's view. It doesn't look as though he's touched it. It actually looks as though his boot comes down alongside it. So that's the referee's view. So you can understand why the referee, he didn't even give a free kick. You can understand that.”

The Gazette has launched a new WhatsApp NUFC channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates directly to your phone. Simply click this link to join our NUFC WhatsApp channel.

Jay Bothroyd, appearing alongside Gallagher on Ref Watch, added: “Again, I agree with Dermot in that situation. I think to the referee, it does seem like he's just put his heel down and then his foot. But then from the other view behind, obviously he's caught him. But I think that's just an unfortunate challenge. I don't think that's a yellow card. I just think that's a foul.

“I think sometimes we can get caught in these dilemmas where you're like, everything is a yellow card. I don't think that's a yellow card. I just think that's a foul. They're both going there to win the ball. It looks a certain way when you slow it down. But I just think that's an unfortunate coming together, to be honest.”

Mukiele, meanwhile, was booked in the first half following a heavy collision with Dan Burn, one that ultimately forced the Magpies man off the pitch just minutes later. Burn was then taken to hospital after, complaining that he was struggling to breathe following the incident.

On Mukiele’s foul on Burn, Gallagher added: “I think the difference here is one player got the ball, one didn't. Half a second the other way, it could have been Dan Burn that caught Mukiele.

“Both players are challenging for the ball. It's inevitable they're going to collide. As I say, the only difference is Dan Burn... if you look, that's how fractional it is. Fractions before, he gets there first.

“It's just really unfortunate. But these things happen in football, don't they?”

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice