Latest on Domino's mission to open new South Shields takeaway amid childhood obesity concerns

Plans for a Domino’s Pizza store at a South Shields retail development, blocked by council planners over childhood obesity concerns, are due to be decided by a Government planning inspector.

An appeal has been lodged against South Tyneside Council’s recent decision to refuse an application for a hot food takeaway at the retail site off Claypath Lane and Crossgate.

The town centre site once housed an office block but following its demolition, the land was left vacant for several years.

Appeal lodged over refused Domino’s Pizza store at new retail development in South Shields (Appeal site pictured in March, 2026)placeholder image
Appeal lodged over refused Domino’s Pizza store at new retail development in South Shields (Appeal site pictured in March, 2026) | LDRS

A planning statement submitted with the application noted “the intention is for the premises to be occupied by Domino’s Pizza under a national franchise model”, with a “high-quality, professionally specified extraction and ventilation system”.

Planning documents said the operation would be “predominantly delivery-led, with the majority of orders fulfilled through home delivery supported by online and telephone ordering systems” along with a customer seating area to “allow customers to consume food on the premises”.

Those behind the scheme added the proposed use would be “sustainable, proportionate [and] compatible with the approved development of which the unit forms a part” and represented a “low-intensity form of takeaway use that is typical of modern delivery-based operators”.

The applicant’s planning statement added that the proposed development would create between 20–30 long-term jobs, comprising a mix of full-time and part-time positions.

During a council public consultation exercise on the plans, South Tyneside Council’s public health department called for the plan to be refused, noting there were “lots of fast-food outlets and restaurants” in the Beacon and Bents ward “which makes it increasingly difficult for people to make healthier food choices”.

It was also noted that “fast food is often a popular choice with children and younger people and can be considered a contributing factor to the increasing levels of obesity.”

The main reason for refusal, set out in a council decision report, was linked to the principle of the hot food takeaway use at the site, existing obesity levels in the area, and the plans clashing with council planning guidance and the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) “with regards to health and well being, tackling unhealthy lifestyles and obesity”.

It was noted that the proposed hot food takeaway would “introduce a further such use in an area where Year 6 obesity levels (National Child Measurement Programme) significantly exceed the 10 per cent threshold”, set out in the council’s planning guidance around “hot food takeaways and health”.

Council documents said this planning guidance document falls against a backdrop of public health, planning and environmental health departments’ efforts to “promote healthier living and tackle obesity by managing the proliferation of hot food takeaways”.

In the case of the Domino’s Pizza hot food takeaway application, it was noted that the site was in the Beacon and Bents ward where recent published data for 2023/2024 showed that “33.74 per cent of Year 6 children from this ward are very overweight (obese)”, which the council described as “significantly over” the 10 per cent obesity level threshold set out in council guidance.

It was noted that the council’s planning guidance also aligns with national planning policy, which “sets out that applications for hot food takeaways should be refused in locations where there is evidence that a concentration of such uses is having an adverse impact on local health”.

The council decision report also said national planning policy “says that unless the location is within a designated town centre, hot food takeaways should be refused that are within walking distance of schools”.

In the case of the Claypath retail park unit, it was noted that “the proposed outlet would be less than 400 metres from St Bede’s Catholic Primary & Nursery School”, with the application site described in council documents as “lying in close proximity to a school”.

It was also noted that the “policy conflicts” around the proposed hot food takeaway could “not be overcome through the use of planning conditions.”

Applicants previously said the “occupation of the unit by Domino’s Pizza provides a realistic, deliverable and long-term solution which will bring a vacant or underutilised premises back into active commercial use”.

It was also argued that recent planning appeal decisions “confirm that any perceived concerns about health, highways or amenity cannot reasonably or robustly justify refusal.”

The applicant has now lodged an appeal with the national Planning Inspectorate and the Secretary of State will appoint a planning inspector to rule on the planning application, which could see the council’s refusal ruling being upheld or thrown out.

An appeal statement uploaded to South Tyneside Council’s planning portal website sets out the appellant’s case, which it states is based on a “narrow issue of principle”.

The appeal statement said that the “question for the inspectoris whether a delivery-led hot food takeaway, proposed within a modern commercial unit that already benefits from an unrestricted Class E use, can properly be refused on the basis of generalised public health concerns derived from non-statutory guidance and ward-wide obesity statistics, notwithstanding the absence of demonstrable site-specific planning harm”.

It was noted that the appeal proposal “seeks only to regularise the sui generis classification required by the proposed operator” Domino’s Pizza and “does not involve any increase in floorspace, alteration to the building envelope, expansion of the site or intensification of built form”.

The appellant maintained that the council’s refusal decision is “fundamentally flawed in policy, legal and evidential terms” and said “planning permission should be granted”.

Technical arguments around the council’s application of planning rules and guidance are set out in the appeal statement, with the document claiming the council refusal decision has an “over-reliance on non-statutory guidance and a failure to properly assess material considerations”.

It was also noted that the emerging South Tyneside Local Plan “is not adopted and can only be afforded limited weight” in relation to the appeal.

In terms of a “fallback position” for the site, council planners noted the appeal unit benefits from “an unrestricted Class E use” which would “permit cafés and restaurants selling hot food for on-site consumption, with no control over nutritional content, customer numbers, opening hours or dwell times”.

In this context, those behind the appeal said “such uses could lawfully generate greater levels of activity and congregation than the proposeddelivery-led Domino’s Pizza operation”.

It was argued that “appeal precedent confirms that Class E fallback rights significantly diminish the weight that can be attached to perceived harms” and that “the failure to properly consider the fallback position is a fatal flaw in the [council’s] refusal decision”.

The appeal statement added: “The refusal relies on ward-wide childhood obesity statistics and generalised assertions about food environments.

“No evidence is provided to demonstrate a causal link between this proposal and harm to health outcomes [and] correlation is relied upon where causation is required.

“National policy does not support refusal based on abstract health data alone [and] inspectors have consistently rejected such approaches where site-specific harm is not demonstrated.

“The proximity of the site to a primary school does not justify refusal, national policy does not impose blanket exclusion zones and SPD22 cannot introduce such controls in the absence of adopted policy support.

“The public health objection therefore attracts limited weight.”

Although the appellant said the “primary position” in the appeal “is that planning permission should be granted without restriction”, those behind the appeal said they would be willing to “accept a temporary permission or operator-specific condition should the inspector consider it necessary.”

A decision on the appeal will be published on the Planning Inspectorate’s website once a ruling has been made.

For more information on the plan and appeal, visit South Tyneside Council’s planning portal website and search reference: 250712

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice