Verdict in for new five-bed shared house amid concerns over the number of HMO plans for South Tyneside

Plans for a new five-bedroom house in multiple occupation (HMO) in South Shields have been blocked by borough councillors.

South Tyneside Council’s Planning Committee, at a meeting this week, discussed and voted on plans for 33-35 Vine Street in the town’s Biddick and All Saints ward.

General view of Vine Street, South Shieldsplaceholder image
General view of Vine Street, South Shields | Google/LDRS

Proposals included living, kitchen and dining space and two en-suite bedrooms on the ground floor, as well as two en-suite bedrooms on the first floor and one bedroom with an off-suite.

The application falls against a backdrop of South Tyneside Council’s recent decision to launch an “immediate” borough-wide Article 4 Direction removing permitted development rights for small HMOs, meaning that planning permission is now needed for all HMOs across the borough.

In recent weeks, increasing numbers of HMO applications have been submitted to the council’s planning department for smaller developments of up to six bedrooms.

A planning application from developers noted that work already started at 33-35 Vine Street in June, 2025, but has not been completed, while a planning statement submitted with the HMO application noted there would be “no external works other than the addition of a bin store and cycle spaces”.

It was noted that “all the properties developed by Beaumont and Partners [the listed agent for the scheme] will be professionally designed and managed” and that properties are “aimed at young working professionals” with “every property having a dedicated property manager” to “ensure that the HMO is managed appropriately”.

Those behind the scheme added “the proposal will therefore make an efficient use of existing housing stock, providing additional, high-quality accommodation that supports local housing needs without adversely impacting the character of the area or the amenities of neighbouring occupiers”.

It was also argued that the HMO could be “easily absorbed into the neighbourhood” and that “given the minimal change in the bedrooms […] the comings and goings of five tenants will not be significantly greater than those of a family unit.”

South Tyneside Council’s planning department, in a report published ahead of a decision-making Planning Committee this week, had recommended the HMO for approval.

Council planners said the “greatest weight in deciding this application needs to be given to the NPPF [national planning policy framework] as opposed to local planning policy, given that the application includes housing development and the council’s housing land supply/delivery deficiencies”.

It was noted that the proposal would “provide social and economic gains by contributing to reducing the current shortfall in terms of housing supply” and that “no significant harm or adverse impacts have been identified in respect of visual and residential amenity, biodiversity, highway safety, or in respect of crime/antisocial behaviour/fear of crime and flood risk/drainage.”

During a council public consultation exercise on the plans there were around four objections received raising concerns about increased noise and disturbance, antisocial behaviour, increased parking pressures, the HMO being close to schools and sheltered accommodation and the plans being “out of keeping with [the] family-orientated character of the area.”

Councillor Rachael Taylor, Biddick and All Saints ward councillor, called the application into the Planning Committee for decision, and members of the panel discussed the application at South Shields Town Hall on February 9, 2026.

Council planners, in a presentation to the committee, said the five-bed HMO proposal would not be “significantly different” to the existing three-bedroom dwelling in terms of increased footfall and “comings and goings”, given the “mixed-use nature of the area” which included traffic linked to shops and local services.

In terms of concerns around “cumulative impact” issues, it was noted there was one other licensed HMO within 100 metres of the site” and council planners said the Vine Street HMO’s rooms met licensing standards.

On crime and antisocial behaviour matters, council planners said the Planning Committee had to consider the use of the building rather than its future occupants, although police, in a consultation statement, raised concerns about the “number of HMO applications in the South Tyneside area” and asked for “all of the [proposed Vine Street HMO] rooms to be single, as well as being single sex occupation.”

Councillor Rachael Taylor, Biddick and All Saints ward councillor, speaking at the Planning Committee, referenced wider community concerns about “the absence of enforceable management” of HMOs and noted other applications in the area under consideration which, she said, represented an “emerging” cumulative impact of HMOs.

The councillor said that safeguarding was also a concern as the Vine Street building was near SS Peter and Paul Catholic Primary School and noted the school had submitted a formal objection and that there were concerns that the HMO’s increased density and turnover risks “intensifying” wider security and safety issues.

Other concerns raised by Cllr Taylor included the plans leading to increased parking pressures and highway safety issues , the consultation on the HMO application “falling far short of what is reasonable” and existing antisocial behaviour issues in the area, and the ward councillor asked for the HMO application to be refused, or for a decision to be deferred to allow further consultation with the school.

Council planners, responding, said the Planning Committee could only look at existing HMOs within the area, that the council doesn’t have control over who occupies HMOs, and that the “small size” of the Vine Street HMO would not have a “significant difference” in terms of parking, with no objections from the council’s highways authority.

There were a number of questions and comments from members of the Planning Committee, with councillor Paul Dean and councillor Joan Hamilton referencing consultation comments from the council’s community safety team and the police.

Councillor Kate Owens-Palmer said she had concerns about existing crime issues in the area where the application site was based and the “concentration of dwellings in the area.”

Councillor David Kennedy asked why the school was initially “missed out” of a consultation as a neighbouring property and council planners, responding, said that “statutory requirements” around consultation had been met.

Meanwhile, councillor Chris Davies suggested the five-bed HMO was about “extending the [applicant’s] return on investment” and criticised the inclusion of an off-suite bathroom for one of the proposed HMO rooms, asking for this room to be removed and for more communal space to be added instead.

Council planners, responding to Cllr Davies, said this was not possible as the Planning Committee did not have the remit to change the description of the development which had been submitted to the council.

Councillor Shirley Ford added the council planners’ report presented to the committee referenced three HMOs on Stanhope Road which showed “evidence of significant accumulation [of HMOs] in the area” and raised concerns about the proposed Vine Street HMO changing the character of the area from family housing.

At the close of the debate, Cllr Owens-Palmer proposed to reject the planning application, against the recommendation of council planning officers to approve, describing the HMO as “an unsuitable development for that particular residential street.”

Reasons for refusal agreed by the Planning Committee following a vote included the “cumulative effects on the area”, the impact on the character of the area and the amenity of existing residents.

The applicant has the right to challenge the council’s refusal decision by lodging an appeal with the Secretary of State.

For more information on the HMO plan, visit South Tyneside Council’s planning portal website and search reference: 250775

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice