South Shields shop raided twice in one day by the same thief - here's his punishment

The case was heard at South Tyneside Magistrates' Court.placeholder image
The case was heard at South Tyneside Magistrates' Court.

A South Shields shop was raided twice in one day by the same thief.

A South Tyneside shoplifter with a taste for Stella Artois pinched two 18-can packs three hours apart from the same store, a court heard.

Colin Rutter, 35, picked up an £18 case at Morrisons in Ocean Road, South Shields, at 4.06pm on Wednesday, April 6, and made off without paying.

Rutter, of Beach Road, also South Shields, returned at 7.41pm and stole another, prosecutor Glenda Beck told borough magistrates.

Ordered to leave Ocean Road area for 48 hours

And eight days later, he was ordered by police to leave the Ocean Road area for 48-hours, due to concerns around anti-social behaviour.

To legally compel him to do so, officers issued him with a prohibitive section 35 direction at around 8pm on Sunday, June 14.

However, they found him still there 45 minutes later, leading to his arrest for breaching the directive.

Mrs Beck added: “The thefts took place at Morrisons in Ocean Road, where CCTV was checked, and staff recognised Mr Rutter from previous incidents.

“He entered at 4.06pm and took a box of Stella and he returned at 7.41pm and took another box of Stella.

“Each box cost £18, and so the total compensation is £36. He wasn’t interviewed about the offences.

“There was some degree of planning as he went back to the same store.”

Guilty pleas

Rutter, who has nine previous theft or kindred offences to his name, pleaded guilty to two counts of theft from a shop.

He also admitted one count of failing to comply with a section 35 direction to leave an area.

David Forrester, defending, said Rutter had breached the section 35 order because he lived at the time in a street closer to Ocean Road.

Of the thefts, Mr Forrester added: “He has issues surrounding alcohol. He went in and took 18 cans of Stella.

“No doubt it was at the front door, and it tempted him because he has gone back later.

“I think that you can properly conclude that it was isolated, where he had thought of alcohol.

“He tells me that his alcohol consumption has been reducing a lot recently, mainly because he now has his own room. He appears a lot more rational.”

Magistrates ordered Rutter to pay Morrisons £36 compensation and fined him £80, with £85 court costs and a £32 victim surcharge.

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice