Bruno Guimaraes is no Alexander Isak - but Arsenal man should expect full Newcastle United fury

Bruno Guimaraes can expect an intense reception when he returns to Newcastle United in Arsenal colours.

If Mikel Arteta has any sense, he will leave Bruno Guimaraes on the bench on Saturday. Newcastle United’s boo boys have already proved capable of acting as the club’s 12th man this season.

And while Alexander Isak and Sandro Tonali are crucial to Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur, Guimaraes is simply another cog in the Arsenal wheel. The Brazilian has already been in damage-limitation mode.

For what feels like the umpteenth time since leaving Newcastle, Guimaraes has attempted to temper the mood ahead of a passion-fuelled reunion. He said earlier this week: “I was one of the most beloved players during my time there, so it was a difficult decision but, deep down, I felt I needed a new challenge.

We have launched a new NUFC YouTube channel to bring the latest Newcastle United news and analysis. Click this link and subscribe to NUFC Press Box.

"After almost five years at Newcastle, I think I'm driven by challenges and wanted a new one. To be completely honest, it wasn't an easy decision. I had to think long and hard about it at the time. It was very difficult, too. But in the end, I chose to make the move.”

As revealed by The Gazette, Guimaraes left the La Manga pre-season camp in tears once his move to Arsenal was agreed. He confirmed this last month in a separate effort to placate the Newcastle fan base.

Guimaraes is no Isak. The Swede refused to train or play for the Magpies despite having Champions League football secured. His effort derailed the Saudi-backed project and, 15 months on, Newcastle are yet to recover.

Nor is he comparable to Tonali, who has made no secret of the financial and lifestyle considerations behind his departure. At 29, Guimaraes’ desire for a new challenge is easier to understand.

Newcastle finished 12th and a rebuild was inevitable. Anthony Gordon and Tonali departing - combined with Isak a year earlier - underlined how the financial rules have stalled the club’s trajectory.

However, the Brazilian is also the one who endeared himself to Newcastle fans more than any other. Those tears after the Wembley final - where he became the first captain since Jimmy Scoular to lift a domestic trophy - cemented his adopted Geordie status.

Disappointment - not vitriol - is the prevailing emotion. Guimaraes was on track to stand alongside Alan Shearer in the pantheon of St James’ Park. Now, his legacy is a rung or two below.

The passing of time may prove kind to him. David Ginola was booed as a Spurs player and is now regarded as a Newcastle hero. Guimaraes fits a similar mould: an overseas star who, for a time, carried the dreams of a fan base before leaving on a sour note.

By contrast, Isak is unlikely to enjoy the same redemption arc. But this weekend - just three months after abandoning Newcastle - he should expect the full force of the terraces.

This is a fan base who jeered the likes of Ayoze Perez upon return despite the Magpies languishing in the doldrums. If there is any edge to be gained, Newcastle supporters will find it.

Isak and Tonali froze under the backlash earlier this season. Matthias Jaissle’s men are already underdogs. Guimaraes turning up in red and white will only intensify what is expected to be a raucous St James’ Park atmosphere. Take note, Arteta.

Your next Newcastle United read:

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice