Goalless and toothless at the break, you could argue there was a marked improvement at the Emirates in comparison to the very low base set at Bramall Lane. But in the second half, as United retreated further and further back, the wheels came off.
Who performed best and who had a shocker? Here’s Miles Starforth’s player ratings...
5. Jamal Lewis - 5
Handed his first Premier League start in more than a month, had a tough night against Saka. Photo: CATHERINE IVILL
6. Jonjo Shelvey - 3
Struggled to beat the first man with his corners, didn't do nearly enough with and without the ball alongside an overworked Longstaff. Photo: Catherine Ivill
7. Matty Longstaff - 5
Recalled after a two-game absence from the starting XI, covered a lot of ground and moved the ball intelligently. Photo: Catherine Ivill
8. Miguel Almiron - 7
Threatened early in the game down the right, never stopped running and working for the team. Photo: Pool