'Liability' - Former Newcastle United favourite refutes suggestions of surprise midfield move

Newcastle United’s midfield options were the subject of a discussion on BBC Newcastle.

Newcastle United’s midfield options have become the subject of ongoing debate after a summer of change at St James Park.

The loss of key duo Sandro Tonali and Bruno Guimaraes meant the Magpies headed into their first season under new head coach Matthias Jaissle with a new-look engine room. Stalwart Joelinton is yet to feature this season as he works his way back from injury - and that has meant there has been a youthful feel about the United midfield during the first month of the campaign.

placeholder image
Getty Images

Joe Willock has become the senior figure at the age of 27 with Jacob Ramsey and summer signing Nico Gonzalez next up in terms of experience at the ages of 25 and 24 respectively. However, summer signings Aladji Bamba and Sean Steur and academy product Lewis Miley are all under the age of 21 - and there have been some suggestions Jaissle should pitch veteran defender Fabian Schar into his midfield in instil some experience and knowhow.

However, former Magpies centre-back Steve Howey has refuted such a suggestion and believes Schar’s temperament means the Swiss defender can ‘be a liability’ when the game gets physical.

He told BBC Newcastle: "I get the suggestion, I just think in this particular game [against Hull], I think he's a good player, but in this game if you would bring him in as it will be a battle in there. I think Schar's temperament can be the type that silently loses his rag a little bit and gives away needless fouls. There's no doubt he can play football, I'm just thinking about the physicality of it.

"You don't want to be going into nearly three weeks [of international break] with two loses on the bounce, so I get what is being seen, but sometimes I think he can be a liability. If he gives away an early foul, I guarantee it's not going to be long before he gets another one. The last thing you want to do is lose a man early doors. I think you've got to give him a little bit of time."

Schar has not started a Premier League match for Newcastle since January and has missed training during the international break as he looks to get back to full fitness after an extended spell on the sidelines.

News you can trust since 1849
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice